The Young and the Restless has kept fans on the hook about the identity of Aristotle Dumas, despite Us Weekly confirming that Billy Flynn is playing the role. But there could be much more to this intriguing character. Is he one of the famous Young and Restless characters from the past? Many fans seem to think so.
Could Billy Flynn’s Aristotle Dumas actually be Cane Ashby in The Young and the Restless?
One strange, potentially dramatic possibility is that Aristotle Dumas is actually Cane Ashby. Cane disappeared from Genoa City years ago, and his fate was never truly resolved. Though Billy Flynn has seemingly revealed who Aristotle Dumas is, soap operas often use misdirection—especially before major plot points like this one.
Moreover, Billy Flynn may be playing Aristotle Dumas, but Dumas could still turn out to be Cane Ashby. One key hint comes from the actor himself. Flynn compared Aristotle to Jay Gatsby from the novel The Great Gatsby. Gatsby is known for his rags-to-riches story. Ashby, too, vanished six years ago, and now a figure called Dumas has arrived with immense wealth and influence. This small, cryptic comment from Flynn seems to further fuel fan theories.
Moreover, Daniel Goddard, who plays Cane, took to Instagram to say that there is a big announcement coming. This also hints at something developing.
The Young and the Restless has given considerable importance to the role of Aristotle Dumas. With a prominent actor stepping into the role and such a long, suspenseful buildup, most fans expect Aristotle Dumas to become a major player in the storyline. That would especially be true if he turns out to be Cane Ashby.
Ashby’s return would bring an added layer of drama. It could also introduce a compelling backstory and enrich the show’s world-building.
Young and Restless will make this big revelation on the June 20, 2025, episode. But this episode may not feature the supposed true identity of Aristotle Dumas, if there is any at all.